Finance

Anthropic's Record IPO Failed to Save the AI Trade: What Went Wrong

Unpack why the largest IPO in U.S. history failed to revive the AI trade, from chip export worries and an OpenAI price war to a buy-the-dip habit under strain.

Farhan Khan's avatar
Farhan KhanStaff
4 min read

Key Takeaways

  • A record IPO is not a rescue: Anthropic closed up 17% from its IPO price, yet the Nasdaq Composite fell 2.25%.
  • Export controls are the plot twist, with documents showing approval of more than 879,000 AI chips for Chinese companies.
  • The Anthropic and OpenAI price war is eating the upside, as combined revenue growth slid from 75% to 48% sequentially.
  • Buy the dip has lost its shine, and Nvidia's ongoing declines are the reason.
  • Asia took the hit too, with the Nikkei 225 down 4.54% and the Kospi down 4.74%.
  • Monday's Anthropic options are the next test of whether retail investors still believe.
Graphic of a falling market line beside the figure -2.25% and the Anthropic name.
Anthropic IPO Sparks Sell-Off

Anthropic's record-setting debut should have been a victory lap. The largest IPO in U.S. history landed with a thud for everyone except the company and its investors.

Traders had billed it as a clearing event, a reset button after months of choppy trading. Instead the Nasdaq Composite closed down 2.25%, and the mood in Asia turned darker by morning.

So what happened to the savior? Chip export worries, a price war and a fading buy-the-dip habit all crowded the stage. Let's get started.

Celebrating a Record IPO

The champagne cork popped, and the room forgot to cheer. Think of Anthropic's debut as a blockbuster premiere where the audience walks out into a thunderstorm. The largest IPO in U.S. history delivered for the company and its backers.

The stock closed up 17% from its IPO price and raised more than $81 billion. Many investors read that as good news for capital spending across tech, and they had hoped the listing would work as a clearing event after months of choppy trading.

Yet the hoped-for spark never caught. The listing revived animal spirits for Anthropic, not for the AI trade at large. Winning the day and rescuing the sector turned out to be two separate jobs.

Watching the AI Trade Slip

Imagine throwing a party to lift the mood and watching guests head for the exits. Thursday's tape looked like that. The sell-off was broad, and tech took the heaviest blows.

The Nasdaq Composite closed down 2.25%. The Dow Jones entered a technical correction at its intraday low, and the VIX, Wall Street's volatility gauge, reached its highest level since March. The early buyers at the listing had sold into the gains by the close.

Asia felt the aftershock on Friday, with Japan's Nikkei 225 down 4.54% and South Korea's Kospi down 4.74%. Global stocks were pushed toward their longest losing run in three years, a long way from the clearing event traders had pictured.

Untangling Chip Export Fears

Export controls are the quiet plot twist in this story. Picture a toll booth on the world's busiest chip highway, with Washington suddenly checking every trunk. Investors already feared an Asia sales slump before Thursday began.

Then the headlines piled on. Short seller Hunterbrook Media alleged that firmware sold by AMD had turned up in U.S.-blacklisted companies, and AMD stock closed down more than 7%. The House Foreign Affairs Committee released documents showing approval of more than 879,000 AI chips for Chinese companies.

AMD told CNBC it complies with U.S. law, and an allegation is not a verdict. But the Nvidia espionage scandal still hangs in the air, and California has opened an investigation into whether China improperly obtained Nvidia's advanced chips or confidential information. The chip trade runs on trust, and trust is thin.

Fighting an AI Price War

Two heavyweights are swinging at each other, and the bill lands on everyone. Anthropic and OpenAI are locked in a price war, the kind where both fighters bleed while the crowd roars.

Dan Niles, founder of Niles Investment Management, put numbers on the bruises. Combined revenue growth for the pair slid from 75% sequentially in Q2 to 48% in Q3. Combined losses climbed from $7.9 billion to about $8.4 billion.

That matters well beyond two companies. Fierce price competition threatens the revenue and profit potential of AI and the capex flowing into it. Niles calls himself a circumspect bull, and he points out that a rough market still paid off for investors holding the right combination of longs and shorts.

Reading the AI Trade Ahead

The old reflex, buy the dip and wait, has hit a wall. JJ Kinahan of Cboe Global Markets calls it a reset of AI in general. He describes an attitude change: investors can't buy things blindly and expect them all to go up.

Nvidia's ongoing declines have shaken confidence in that habit. Kinahan called Friday a wild card, either a final flush out or a bounce that leaves the market in no man's land. Monday brings the better test, when options on Anthropic start trading.

Those options show whether retail investors back the company in force, since retail tends to buy calls when it expects gains. Resolution is possible if commercial and regulatory clarity emerges over the next few months. Until then, selectivity beats faith.

Long Story Short

Anthropic's IPO did its job for Anthropic. The stock closed up 17% and the company raised more than $81 billion. It just can't carry an entire sector on its back. The wobble came from deeper places: export-control scrutiny, a price war that is lifting combined losses, and investors who no longer trust the dip. The Nikkei and Kospi each fell over 4%, and the VIX topped 29 intraday. Pick your spots. Dan Niles's lesson from a tough year is that the right mix of longs and shorts still pays, while blind faith does not. Watch Monday's Anthropic options for a read on retail appetite. Commercial and regulatory clarity is what the market is waiting for, and it hasn't arrived yet. Until it does, stay curious, stay selective, and keep your nerve.

Finsights

From signal to strategy — insights that drive better decisions.

Must Consider

Things to keep an eye on — the factors that could influence your takeaway from this story/topic

Core considerations

A hot IPO feels like proof of life, but one deal can't repair an entire trade. Anthropic raised more than $81 billion, yet the market treated it as a footnote to export-control headlines and a price war. The data points to a problem with profit, not enthusiasm: combined losses for Anthropic and OpenAI rose to about $8.4 billion. The trend is a market that wants clarity before it offers conviction.

Key elements to understand

Our Two Cents

Our no-nonsense take on the trends shaping the market — what you should know

Our take

If you hold AI names, today's lesson is humility. A record debut can lift one stock while the neighborhood sinks, and the pain showed up in chips, neoclouds and hyperscalers alike. Niles's 2022 comparison is the useful part: money was still made that year with the right combination of longs and shorts. The downside of that strategy is effort, since it demands more attention and conviction than buying everything and waiting.

Trends that shape the narrative

Similar Reads

Latest articles on Finance