Business

Musk's SpaceX Eyes S&P 500 Entry Through a Tesla Merger Gambit

Discover how a SpaceX-Tesla merger gives Elon Musk a possible side door into the S&P 500, what index funds must do next, and why Tesla shareholders hold the final vote.

Farhan Khan's avatar
Farhan KhanStaff
4 min read

Key Takeaways

  • SpaceX was turned away by S&P Global, so Tesla's existing S&P 500 seat is the tempting side door.
  • Index inclusion is mechanical: funds buy the stock whether their owners notice or not.
  • Musk controls the SpaceX vote, but Tesla shareholders get the final say.
  • Regulators, from antitrust to national security, are a second gate after the shareholder vote.
  • Tesla's earnings multiple is steep, and some of the deal buzz is likely already priced in.
  • A merged giant tilts the index further toward AI, and concentration brings risk.
A rocket and an electric car approach a glowing S&P 500 doorway on a dark financial chart background.
SpaceX Tesla Merger Talks

Elon Musk wants to merge his two biggest companies. SpaceX wants a seat in the S&P 500. Those two ambitions just found each other.

SpaceX was refused a fast track into the benchmark after its June Nasdaq listing. Tesla, an S&P 500 member since December 2020, offers a way around the velvet rope. Together the two companies carry a market value of about $3.4 trillion.

So is this a clever shortcut or an expensive tangle? Let's get started.

Chasing an S&P 500 Entry

Picture a velvet rope outside the most exclusive club in finance. SpaceX tried to talk its way past it and was turned away. Now Elon Musk is eyeing a side entrance, and it runs straight through Tesla.

S&P Global said on June 4 that it was holding its entry requirements steady, a rebuff to SpaceX, which had pressed for a faster track for big new listings. Tesla, though, has sat in the S&P 500 since December 2020. Fold the two together and Musk gets a route SpaceX could not find alone.

Is that a clean workaround? Not quite. SpaceX still falls short of some entry requirements, including a full year of trading history, and inclusion after a merger is not automatic.

Merging SpaceX and Tesla

Musk calls the idea a good one, and the logic is tidy: put the empire under one roof and squeeze out synergies while he chases pricey long shots, from humanoid robots to space-based data centers and Mars.

The two already share projects, including the Terafab chip plant in Texas, and SpaceX absorbed Musk's AI company xAI before listing. Both boards have formed special committees, and Musk has stepped back from negotiations. JPMorgan Chase analysts expect an all-stock deal led by SpaceX.

Yet nothing is signed. Musk says no terms are agreed, while a report points to an announcement as soon as December. The prediction market Kalshi puts the odds of a tie-up before next May at 59%.

Tracking S&P 500 Index Flows

Index inclusion is plumbing, not a popularity contest. Hold an S&P fund in your 401(k) and its manager is compelled to buy every stock in proportion to its weight, whether you knew it or not.

Roughly $16 trillion sits in index trackers, and TD Securities' Reid Noch estimates a combined company's addition sparks about $100 billion of index-fund buying. Based on recent prices, the merged outfit slots in as the fifth largest member of the benchmark.

The flow cuts both ways. If the merged company is not added, passive funds must sell the shares they receive in the deal. That pressure alone moves prices around the edges, a quiet tug-of-war most savers never see.

Facing Tesla Merger Hurdles

Musk holds the keys at SpaceX and only a seat at the table at Tesla. That asymmetry is the plot twist of the whole saga.

At SpaceX his voting control is overwhelming, so approval there is not in doubt. At Tesla he owns about 19.8% of the shares, and Musk says the deal needs a 50% vote of all shares, not just those cast. He calls that a high hurdle.

Regulators add another gate. Counterpoint Research's Kevin Li flags antitrust scrutiny, national security questions tied to SpaceX's military contracts and cross-border reviews. Musk's roughly $445 million in super PAC spending for GOP candidates adds political static.

Weighing Valuation Risk

Big dreams carry big price tags. SpaceX listed in June and quickly reached a valuation of up to $2.6 trillion, a number that asks investors to pay now for projects still on the drawing board.

Tesla shares are down 13% this year and still trade at more than 180 times expected earnings, versus 18 for the S&P 500 overall. Gary Black of the Future Fund flags massive dilution and all-equity economics, and doesn't expect the deal to look compelling.

A merged giant tilts the benchmark further toward technology, already heavier than at the dot-com peak. VettaFi's Brent Leadbetter says large-cap indexes are edging toward becoming AI investment instruments, and that concentration brings risk.

Long Story Short

Strip away the headlines and the story is simple. SpaceX needs a door into the S&P 500, Tesla holds a key, and both boards are now studying the lock. If you own an S&P index fund, you already own a slice of whatever the index decides. Watch the deal's structure, because passive funds must buy if the combined company gets in and sell what they receive if it does not. And don't treat a merger rumor as a sure thing: some of that excitement is likely already priced into Tesla stock. Tesla shareholders get the final say, and Musk himself admits that vote is a steep climb. Whatever happens, the index keeps drifting toward a heavier AI tilt, and concentration brings risk. Stay curious, stay diversified, and read the fine print.

Finsights

From signal to strategy — insights that drive better decisions.

Must Consider

Things to keep an eye on — the factors that could influence your takeaway from this story/topic

Core considerations

A merger headline is not a merger. Musk says no terms are agreed and calls the Tesla vote a high hurdle, while regulators eye antitrust and national security angles given SpaceX's military contracts. With a deal widely expected, some of the upside is likely already priced into Tesla stock. The index shortcut is real, but it is anything but automatic, and a bigger AI-heavy index carries concentration risk of its own.

Key elements to understand

Our Two Cents

Our no-nonsense take on the trends shaping the market — what you should know

Our take

Treat this saga like a weather forecast, not a prophecy. The index mechanics are real, and the money flows are big enough to nudge prices, but a deal still needs boards, regulators and Tesla owners to agree. Chasing a rumor after it has been widely reported rarely pays, since some of it is likely priced in. If you own a broad index fund, the quieter story is how much AI weight you are already carrying.

Trends that shape the narrative

Similar Reads

Latest articles on Business