Business

PERM Overhaul: Labor Department Rewrites Green Card Hiring Rules

Unpacking the Labor Department's proposed PERM rewrite, from 90-day job ads to a two-year layoff lookback, and what the green card hiring overhaul asks of employers before anything becomes final.

Farhan Khan's avatar
Farhan KhanStaff
4 min read

Key Takeaways

  • The Labor Department calls this the first comprehensive PERM reform in nearly 20 years, so it isn't a tweak.
  • Job ads must run at least 90 days, and online recruitment replaces newspaper ads.
  • Layoff lookbacks stretch from six months to two years, a long memory for restructuring employers.
  • Schedule A disappears for nurses, physical therapists and certain other workers, and about 23,835 petitions a year are affected.
  • It's a proposal. Existing PERM rules stay in force until a final rule takes effect.
  • Enforcement is moving in parallel, from suspensions of eight companies to settlements with Instacart and OpenAI.
A graphic of a hiring line with a turnstile labeled PERM, with a calendar page marked 90 days beside it.
PERM Green Card Overhaul

Imagine a line where every foreign hire first has to face one blunt question: did an American want this job? For nearly 20 years, that line has run on rules few outside HR departments ever read.

Now the Labor Department proposes to rebuild it. The plan reaches into recruitment, layoffs and a long-standing shortcut for nurses. Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling says the goal is to put American workers first in line for high-skilled, high-paying jobs.

It's a proposal, not a law, and the fine print matters more than the slogan. Let's get started.

Rewriting Green Card Hiring Rules

Think of PERM as the turnstile at the front of the green card line. Before an employer can sponsor a foreign worker, it has to prove no qualified American wants the job. That turnstile is getting a rebuild.

The Labor Department calls its proposal the first comprehensive reform of PERM regulations in nearly 20 years. Employers must advertise jobs for at least 90 days, and online recruitment replaces mandatory newspaper ads, a switch the department values at $164 million in annual savings.

Yet cheaper ads don't mean easier sponsorship. Employers also have to submit recruitment records, along with any applications or résumés from U.S. workers who applied. The paper trail grows even as the newsprint disappears.

Tightening Layoff Lookback Windows

Layoffs now cast a long shadow. Picture a company that trims its American staff, then waits for the headlines to fade before filing sponsorship paperwork.

Current rules generally look back six months. The proposal stretches that to two years for the same or similar occupations in the same area of employment. The department calls the longer window "a more meaningful safeguard" against exactly that waiting game.

But the stakes are lopsided for some employers. Klein, a former senior DHS official, points to technology companies that restructure regularly. In his view, this is more than an administrative burden, because it can block an employer from pursuing sponsorship altogether.

Ending Schedule A Shortcuts

Schedule A has been the express lane of labor certification. Professional nurses, physical therapists and certain workers with exceptional ability in the sciences or arts skip the standard process. The proposal closes that lane.

The Labor Department says it can no longer confirm a nationwide shortage of workers exists. It adds that federal immigration law doesn't authorize it to exempt occupations from the labor-market test. The department estimates about 23,835 Schedule A petitions a year were filed between fiscal years 2023 and 2025.

Klein warns that removal adds time, expense and uncertainty for employers. Given the staffing challenges facing healthcare employers, he says the consequences reach well beyond immigration processing.

Cracking Down on Green Card Pipelines

The rewrite doesn't arrive alone. It lands in the middle of an enforcement push, with Vice President JD Vance's Anti-Fraud Taskforce setting the tone.

In October, Labor Secretary Sonderling suspended eight companies from PERM, among them Microsoft, Adobe, Cognizant and Infosys. The Justice Department has also reached settlements with Instacart and OpenAI over alleged discrimination against U.S. workers in PERM recruitment. IBM says it is dropping visa and green card sponsorship for most affected roles in IBM Consulting.

Not everyone accepts the framing. Microsoft says about 80% of its roughly 6,000 H-1B applications last fiscal year sought extensions or status changes for existing employees. Suspensions don't cancel H-1B status either, since PERM is the pipeline, not the visa.

Watching the Rulemaking Clock

A proposed rule is a draft, not a verdict. The White House has finished its review, but that doesn't make the changes law, and employers must keep following existing PERM requirements until a final rule takes effect.

Once the proposal appears in the Federal Register, the Labor Department seeks public comments for 60 days. Open questions remain, including whether fully remote jobs stay eligible, face minimum in-person requirements or are excluded. The proposal also limits a certification to one initial I-140 petition filed within 180 days.

So the real story sits in the comment file. Klein puts it plainly: the impact depends on what the department finalizes and how it administers the new requirements.

Long Story Short

Strip away the jargon and the proposal is a bet on friction. Longer ads, a longer layoff memory and fewer shortcuts all push employers to prove their case harder. Whether that opens doors for American workers is the open question, as former DHS official Adam Klein points out. For employers, the practical move is to keep following existing PERM requirements, since nothing changes until the rule is finalised. Track the comment period and map your own layoff history against the two-year window. Healthcare employers that lean on Schedule A have the most homework. For workers waiting in the queue, the mood is understandably tense. Waiting isn't the same as being shut out, though, and the final text is still unwritten. Watch what the Labor Department keeps, trims or drops.

Finsights

From signal to strategy — insights that drive better decisions.

Must Consider

Things to keep an eye on — the factors that could influence your takeaway from this story/topic

Core considerations

Tougher labor market testing sounds like a clean win for American workers, but the sources show the evidence is thin so far. Klein asks whether the changes improve opportunities or simply add costs and delays for employers. The Labor Department's own shortage claim on Schedule A is a policy judgment, not a headcount. And the proposal isn't final, so every projection is a sketch on a draft.

Key elements to understand

Our Two Cents

Our no-nonsense take on the trends shaping the market — what you should know

Our take

We like the idea of a labor market test that reflects how hiring happens today, and online ads are overdue. But a longer layoff memory and a closed Schedule A are blunt tools, and employers and workers pay for blunt tools in delays. The smart reader treats this as a draft worth commenting on, not a headline worth panicking over. Plan for friction, but don't rewrite your hiring strategy before the final text exists.

Trends that shape the narrative

Similar Reads

Latest articles on Business