Pentagon Slams Ukraine's Deep Strikes as Allies Hit Back at Colby
Criticising Ukraine's deep strikes, Pentagon deputy Elbridge Colby urged focus on the front line, while Germany and Britain pushed back and Warsaw heard a green light for a permanent US base.

Key Takeaways
- The Pentagon says Ukraine's deep strikes haven't ended the war or stopped Russian advances, and wants support aimed at the front line instead.
- Colby's favoured tool is the medium-range strike on supply lines, which he calls the most effective route to ending the war.
- Germany's Pistorius called the criticism 'rather stupid', and Britain's Streeting said the strikes saved lives and bought time.
- Wildberries and Ozon warehouses became targets after Kyiv accused them of distributing parts used by the Russian army.
- Warsaw reads Hegseth's 'everything is going in a good direction' as a Pentagon green light for a permanent base, with the White House deciding in early December.

Imagine asking your allies for more missiles and being handed a lecture on aim. That, in short, was Kyiv's week in Brussels. Within minutes of Volodymyr Zelensky appealing for more military aid, the Pentagon's Elbridge Colby told the room that Ukraine's strikes deep inside Russia were not delivering.
The room did not agree. Germany and Britain pushed back hard, and the debate turned into a question about what these attacks are really for. Slowing a war machine, or stiffening an enemy's nerve?
Meanwhile, a very different Pentagon story was unfolding for Poland, where talk of a permanent American base picked up speed. Two stories, one institution, and plenty of nuance. Let's get started.
Challenging the Pentagon's Verdict
Picture shouting through a megaphone at a wall and wondering why the wall still stands. That is how the Pentagon sees Ukraine's deep strikes inside Russia.
On 17 November, at a Ramstein meeting in NATO's Brussels headquarters, Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon's deputy chief, told delegates from about 40 supporting states that the strikes had not helped end the war. They had not helped stop Russian advances on the front line, he said, and the attacks on civilian infrastructure probably hardened Russian society and the Kremlin's readiness to escalate.
Yet the timing stung. His words came minutes after Zelensky, linked in remotely, asked for more military aid, including Patriot missiles. A plea for more, answered with a verdict on method.
Backing Medium-Range Strikes
Colby's message isn't 'stop hitting back'. It's 'swap the sledgehammer for a scalpel'. The scalpel in question is aimed at Moscow's supply lines.
He said US support should focus on strengthening the front and on medium-range attacks that disrupt Russian logistics. His evidence is October: for the second month running, Ukraine regained more territory than it lost, while Russian forces suffered their biggest monthly losses of the entire war. Europe, he added, has taken main responsibility for defending Ukraine, which 'holds the line'.
He also insisted Ukraine shouldn't fight with its hands tied behind its back. The catch is the fine print. The front gets the backing, the deep strikes get the side-eye, and Kyiv still has to read between the two.
Pushing Back Against Pentagon
Not everyone at the table nodded along. German defence minister Boris Pistorius said criticising such strikes is 'rather stupid', and he didn't stop at a shrug.
His case: the strikes hit strategic military sites used for military purposes. If anything deserves criticism, he said, it is the nightly attacks on Ukraine's energy, water and heating infrastructure, which he called terrorism. British defence minister Wes Streeting backed him, saying the strikes helped weaken Putin's war machine, gaining time and saving lives.
So the coalition is split on a basic question. Do deep strikes dent Russia's will, or dent its war effort? Both camps look at the same war and walk away with opposite verdicts.
Hitting Wildberries and Kerch Bridge
Ukraine's reach into Russia follows a pattern, and it runs from refineries to warehouses to a bridge.
Recent months brought strikes mainly on Russian oil refineries, plus warehouses of the e-commerce firms Wildberries and Ozon. Kyiv accuses both of distributing components used by the Russian army, and in November the European Union sanctioned their owners. Colby named Wildberries specifically when warning about civilian targets.
Then came the Kerch Bridge. Zelensky said the road section was destroyed overnight from Monday to Tuesday, and the rail section was damaged too. Ukrainian analysts say rebuilding would take at least a year and is unrealistic under wartime conditions. Colby did not address that attack directly.
Greenlighting a Pentagon-Backed Base
While Brussels argued, Warsaw heard something it has long wanted: a nod.
Deputy prime minister and defence minister Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz said that after meeting US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Poland reads the answer 'everything is going in a good direction' as a green light from the Pentagon for a permanent US base. The final decision belongs to the White House, expected in early December.
Still, nothing is poured in concrete. Deputy minister Paweł Bejda said the Americans haven't picked a location, and the areas around Wrocław, Poznań or Szczecin are candidates, the last close to the sea and a transshipment port. He called the base a matter above political divisions. One approval is in the bag, and the bigger one is pending.
Long Story Short
Strip away the diplomatic polish and the Brussels meeting boiled down to one disagreement. Washington wants Ukraine to hold and strengthen the front and hit supply lines at medium range. Berlin and London see the deeper strikes as a legitimate way to wear down Russia's war machine. Neither side is arguing from nothing. Colby points to October, when Ukraine regained more territory than it lost for the second month running. Pistorius points to the nightly attacks on Ukraine's energy, water and heating networks, and asks why the strikes get the scolding. For readers trying to make sense of the noise, the useful habit is to separate what officials claim from what they measure. Ask which targets are military and which are civilian, and watch the sanctions announcements and the supply-line results. The next marker arrives in early December, when the White House makes its call on a permanent US base in Poland. Until then, the Pentagon has said yes, Washington hasn't, and Kyiv is still waiting for its Patriot missiles.